CỘNG HÒA XÃ HỘI CHỦ NGHĨA VIỆT NAM Độc lập - Tự do - Hạnh phúc | |
| Toa Aru xtt.rrN nAn pHo lu,q,Nu laN uytN riNu RiNu DrroNG Bin iin s6: 55/2024iHNGE-ST' Ngiry 2t/6/2024 Viv ly h6n. tranh clrAp v6 nt16i |
con
NIIAN DANTI
NIIOC CONG HOA XA HOI
CHU NG}IIA VIET NAM
TOA AN NIIAN DAN ]'HANTI
PHO TAN UYI,N, TiNH BiNH
DTIONG
- Thdnh phnn HQi ding xfi
xrt.so,rhiint g6m cd:
-'^lltatn plttin (-ltu
toLr
ttta; Bir l.e TIti
ltltiitr
Hien.
Cac Hoi rlrunt nltun ddn;
Ong Huj,nh Son TAy.
{i
Ong Nguydn Thanh Cdn.
;'
ki plti?n
-foa
/da: IIi NgLr1,6n I'hi M! NhAn -
Thu l<y
6n nhAn dAn
lg . , 'fin
th an
-_^ny ph6
lJ1 dn. tinh IJirrh
I)uonq.
rlial vi(n Kiam.stit
rtan thirnh pna ran (Jyan
:-Dli
tham gia phi€n tba:
.nhdn Ong^ Vd Anh Duy
- KiSm s6r vi6n.
Ngdy 21.th6ng 6 nim 2024,
tai Tod 6n nh6n dAn thdnh phO
.. r
Tan Uy0n x6t xri so thdm c6ng khai vu 6n h6n
nhdn va.giadinh.thu Ij
s6 t48/rO24tTLST_ftNGO
ngay 0?,s/,29?1^:i.riic -L5
hOn. rranrr chip vd nu6iconi.,
qryeiJi"r,''ir.rrjr'*
tr,."
_, xlt s0,!/z!z+!QDXXST-t,NGD
ngdy 20 rh6ng 5 ndrn z.Ozq
iaqryat oirr, r,# pntc, toa sd 26/2024IQDST-HNGD
ngdy 05 thring 6 narn
'
2024, gita"a" orrong
su:---
- NgqtAn don: Bd Ding Thi
M6n, sinh ndrn 1990; noi
cu tru: nhir ridng Nguy6n
gore, tO +, khu pfro.ttruoc H6i, phuong
inai ff"", thdnh ph6 Y.ui
fan U'venl tirt Binh Ducrng: c6 don xin
ving m5t.
inVarrCilne.sirrhrrdnr I9g5:noi
cu,rrt: rrhdriengNguyrin ,,"^,...,.fl ,rlr.],,,1,1*N.,rLr.)(
rrrg. tri .1. 11,,, phi, [)lrtr,ie
IIiri. plrrrirnr: I Irai Iloa.
.vrn
thiir:h pho l rirr .iy
en', ti,h Binh l)unng: vanq nlAt klrorru
rir ly tlo.
NOI DUNG VU AN:
*
Tlrco dcrn khd.i kiAn, bdn
tu. khai, qua trinh gitti quyAt
vu an, nguy€n dctn
bd DQng Thi M€n n"inh btq,.
V€ qtnn lt6 h6n nlton:
ba ,ldn vd 6ng Nguy6n
Vin Cfrng dAng ky
k€t hdn vdo lfl:]":lly:ll' lii.r, ban nhan dan xa iha;h Binh, huyQni{6,-q,,a,,li;'ni,},
chung.nha, ket h6n
so 36/20il. quvdn so0rr2or. .ef1o;theo,ciiy
ia, ru-,i i.et non vg
sdng hanlr phuc
nlru.ng b6t diu tu narn
_chong
zbz t thi
*ryan
*y 'ru ,ra,
,rhuong thu.6n' cai vd. lon ridng vri
rrhatr. Nguyen nhan
lir do dng H6ng.c6 rrguoi
phu nii kldc; kh6ng cd tr6ch nhi6m
gia"dinh.
v6i
Mdc dt
vg ch6ng nhi6u lan
ngoi lqi n6i chuy6n, tim bi€n phdp hdn gin
tinh cAm nhung v6n kh6ng
it,"ann. Hion
,trg ry
";;$;';;
kh6ng cdn' Ba MOn nhfln thAy '
quan tam d6n nhau nen tinh cAm thdn, khdng ai cdn hanhphtc-vqctrong.kh6ngthchengandugcnira,mpcdichh6nnhdnkh6ngdatdugc yOu cAu dugc ly h6n v6i 6ng Cirng' n6n
D[ng Tdrn Nhu' sinh
c6 02 con chung t0.n Nguy6n
Vd con chung: vg
-ch6ng
ra
ngdy t3/10/2022. Tir luc sinh con
Nguy|n Ding ThAi Ph6t. sinh nsdv 07/01/2012 vir
gAn gui'.chdm s6c' nu6i
ri ngudi iruc ti6p vd thu'ong.xuy6n
.f;"'aa" r.r, o, rt'rC"
hiQn c6c con dang s6ng v6i bd
dulc tam sinh li cia con v2r
a"oru
con, narn uat
"a"
tryc tiiip nu6i du.ng 02 con
ly h6n bd Mtln yeu cAu duryc
van. ii v{y, khi vg chiing chung.
6ng Cirng cAp du6ng nudi con'
nu6i con: kh6ng ydu cAu
Vi cdp dudng
kh6ngydu cAu Tda 6n gi6i quytit'
Vi tdi sdn chung, nq chung:
'l
lQ tham gia phi6n
*
d5 clugc oa 6n triQu tap hsp
Bi don 6ng Nguy\n vdn Cftng:
va hoa gi6i' tharn gia phi6n
c6ng khai chung cri
hqp ki6; i.u uiQigiu'o nOp,,ti0p.cAnl
vd kh6ng co vdn bdn trinh bdy
vang *r4t kh6ng c6 li do
iar rt,i t ui"nf,,rng u6, ,#iL
khdi ki6n cria nguyOn don' j ki6n dOi v6i yOu cdu
tham gia phi6n tda phSt
nhan ddn thdnh ph6 tan Uy€n
Dai diQn ViQn ki€m s6t bi6u quan di6rn nhu sau:
tjven thU l1i. vq an la dtng
6n nhan dAn thAnh pnO f an
, VC ttrir tuc t6 tung: Toa
dAvdu.cdc thu tuc to
iin. Th6rnphirrr da ti6n hanh
,hit" q;y:;.b;ttti"r, glai quv€t,u
toa'
a1li
*" ua
lu4t T6 tung ddn su lai phi,cn
Arng theo quy dinfi cra'ri0 i\rng
f]Oi
l:l
tgrng dan su ve phi6n toa
quy dinh cta l]Q luflt t6
toa da thuc hi6n dfing Thu ki ohi6n
gia ro tung cdc.d.uong sr,r dd
ngu,i tharn ;;ffi;:;;
";l"i;";-ir;p hanh pnZp'luat cira
ydu ciu vd ki€n ngh! dd
ti€n ki6rn siit kh6ng co
dung quy Ainn. Oai di'en ,f,U. fliQ,
phpc vi
td tung. khic
Ph4m
V^al-qPg tu nguvCn
bi D[ng Thi MOn vd 6ng Nguv6n
- V6 nOi dung vp 6n:
phep' Bir M0n.xdc. dinh vs
ti5t tron ld h6n nhdn hqp
;;t ;hd
aang ty .hung .ong
"b
dich h6n nhdn kh6ng d4t
.dn quun tdm d6n nhau, muc
ilU]v ,na", u,org ffii!
"i
ei A*
Cirng dd *n:'U1f..IiQu t{p' ni6m
tlusc"lv trOn' e,rq;"n€n .o"ng.r6n
9ry
ving rnflt kh6ng c6 li do'
tham gia phi6n toa nhung
.a. ,dn bAn t6 ipg ai y6ifr* lc "kh6ns'co'van
nguyen don lir c6 cdn
y6u cAu khoi kiQn cta
rrinh bav
do do
ban
i'kien. il;?il;;
G.", .t,r"g1 ba Men y6u ciu clunc nuiri dudng con chung ren Nguy€n Oa"g fa* Nhu, sinh ngiy OzlOfliOl2'vd Nguy6n Ddng rh6i Phdt' sinh ngdy
ln j chi tq nguyQn cria
du.ng nu6i con' dAy
y€u .Ai Ong Crrng cAp 1311012022;kh6ng
ns chung: duong sq
nhfn. Va tdi sin chung,
xrighi
;;il6; ffi id
"errinoi oong"*et
tich trcn' d€ nghi
rit'o1g xem xet' Ttr nhrrnglhdn
cdu Tda a" gia; qr"vei"o" kh6ns. v0u
kiqn cria nguyOn don'
ioin bQ y6u cAu khoi
xdt xri chdp t t an HOi-[o'"g
DINII Curr rOl Ar't:
NHAN
SaukhinghiCncuuc6ctdiliQuc6tronghtiso.vpdndugcthimtrat4iphiontda
qra o*t lu$n t4i phi6n tda' HQi ddng xdt xri nhAn dinh:
,d
"a;;;;;'le
Vi thi.t tuc t6 tung:
quvi5t: dev]i
npl
thAm quvEn gini
quan h0 ph6p 1uflt vd
VC
lu,1l nqn
la-e1a
[1]
Hda, thdnh ph6 Tdn
pho'p-huoc-Hai, phudng Th6i
s6ng t4'i ,o'+, r.nu dinh, bi don sinh
ntnrr ouong va;dya. don da nghi 'l'oa dn nh6n dan th?rnh ph6 Tdn Uv6n t,v6n. tinh
tung dAn ss ndm 2015,
3! ctia Bg lu4t'16
*"".a" Jic, za, 35 vd ;,il;6,.il.'J
J
HQi d6ng xdt xiL xiic dinh
cta Toa iin nhan dan
'l'An
'u an thu6c thArn quy0n gi6i quy0t
thdnh phtr
l_Jv0n. tirrh Ilinh I)r-rong,
Su thar. gia phiCrr roa cua c6c ci.u,crng
su,: bi don 6ng Nguydn VIn Cirng
11]
Cli .
'l'oa duoc
6n tdng. dat, niOm y€t ho-p l0
ldn rhrlr I'rai ciic vdn b6n t6 tgng dd
tham gia phi6n tda nhung vd.rg mdt kh6,g
co ly do; nguy0n clon c6 do, xin xet
xrirvine ,-',dt. Do d6, cdn cri vdo ciic Didu 22i 228 vit 23B
.
ciri np tuat T6 tung ddn su, H6i
aaig ,et ,,i ti€n hdnh xdt xti vu an ving u-rdt cdc duong
su.
',:
l/e not du118.
I,l
q.rii hQ hon nhan: bd Ding
Thi M6n vd ong Nguy6n Van Ciing
co d6ng , . , ,t Ja Ity k0t hon tai U' ban rrhdn ddn xd l-hanh
Binl.r. huy6n FIon
phuoc
Quan, rinh Bi;h theo Gi6y chung nha, kct h6n sfi 36120ll,quy6n
s6 oltzott,ldi6n nhdn hqp ph6p.
Nguydn don bd Ddng Thi M€n xdc dinh,
*rau thuanvg ch6ng Id do 6ng
ctng cso ngudi php nt kh.6c' kh6ng.quan r6n
gia
d6n
dinh. Bd M6n vd 6ng ctng
tiSn tai ia ty th.dn vd ci hai d6u kh6ng ctu'a ra itu.sc
biQn ph6p hdn gin tinh ciir
;L6";. iia ruai, x6c
"q
car. r'tii 6ng Cirng va yeu cAu
9inh
duoc ly h6n.
giii
lhin.g...:n ri.nh
euitrinh quvit vu dn. bd MCn ltl1irlq
lcl t'oa dn cho rh6y 6ng kh6ng c6 rhl6n chi hoa girii ddvo chOng do?rn tr;, d6ng th<ri ba Mdn
ki6n quy6t xin ly h6n. Do do, c6
cdn c&'xiic dinh
j
,a"e.hrrs
ti'i ll?l fr?l.rn ch6ng.g.ita ba Men vd 6ng bung Id irAm treng, AO,r
khlr; .,' th6 kdo ddi. *ruc dich h6n
;-i
nhan kh6ng dat duoc, vi6c
ba Mc; y€u cAu iy rron"uoi
ong . .i: ;/ Cirng ld c6 co sd ch6p nh6n.
"-,/
Ve con chung:
y6, vd 6ng Ctng c6 02 con chung t6n Nguy6n
. .t2l
Ding
.!1 Tdrn Nhu. sinh ngdy 07/012012
ph6t,
vd Nguy6n Dqng Th6i
sin'L
ngay"tittotzozz. Khi ly,hdn,.ba.M5n y6u-ci, clu.qc
trqc ti6p nrOi Juong con chung
uitt,Ong y0u 6ng Cirng ciip duOng nu6i con.
"au
HOi d6ng xdt xt- thd1,: sau khi vo.
chdng s6ng ly th6n, bd MOn
truc ti6p chlm s6c, ru6i dudng 02 chau Nguy6n
Ddng T6rn Nhu vd Nguy6n E{ng
ph6t.
Th6i
Do d6,
cta bt M6n.ctuo.-nroi du.ong-02
ch6u ld c6 .a,i"ii
t:l :1, veu cdu Ong (-Dng
"irap-rf,a".'iijrrijrirrOrg
cap drxirrg nu6i con. xet ddy rd y
chi tr,r nguydn cria bd Mdn n€n
Hoi d6ng xct su ghi nhdn. . . - t3l va oi san chung vii no chung: duong su kh6ng yOu cAu n6n H6i d6ng x6t xri khdng xern xdt, giAi quytlt.
[4] xdt de ,ghi cria dai di6n vi6n
Ki6m s6t tai phi€n tda rd c6 co
sd ch6p nh4n.
t5l va an phi h6n nhdn vd gia
dinh so tharn: c6c duong
su phdi chiu theo quy dinh.
Vi cdc l0 tr€n,
QUYE,1'DINII:
cd'r ciL l<l'roan l DiOLr 28: c6c
Di6u 35. r4i.22i,22g,23g,266,269.21r,2i3
vit
'f6 280 cira 86 luAt
rung
dAn su:
cE, cir c6c Di6u s l. 56. 8r. 82.
g4
83 vd cira Ludr H6n
nhdn vd gia clinh;
crL [)idu 27 Nghi qLryer
s6 326/20t6ruB'rveHl4
.
ngiry 30/1212016 cta
0y
--ca,l ban Thudng i,,q
h6i khoa
Qu6c
14 quy dinh vd m(rc
tt u, .ier,'gia*, ;;,;6p,
O"* ,, vd sir dung 6n phi vd le phi Toa
6n;
nguyen don bd Vdng Glp Vdn vd viQc "ly
1. Chap nhfln yOu cau khdi kiQn cria
nuOi con" voi bi don 6ng Nguydn Vdn H6ng'
h6n, tranh chAp vC
dugc ly h6n vdi 6ng Nguy6n Vdn Cirng' '
quan h€ h6n nhdn: bd E[ng Th1 M€n
Vi
'lA,.r
ten Nguy[n Dqng
Nhu, sinh ngity xxxxxxxxxx
Vi con chung: giao con chung ua NeuyEn oare i#i pl,at, sinh nlay nidnozz cho ba oang Thi Mtin tryc ti6p nu6i du0ng.
d0Lr co quydn vir nghia vq tr6ng
Thi Mi5n vA 6ng Nguy6n Vdn CiLng
Bd D4ng
quy dinh cta phdp luflt. Sau khi ly h6n,
nu6i du6ng, gido d,c con theo norn, ch6m s61,
vu tham nom con md kh6ng ai duqc
tryc ti6p nu6i con co quyAn. nghia ngudi kh6ng
cAn trd ho4c gAy
ti6p nu6i con lanidpng vi6c thdm
c6n trd. Ngudi kh6ng trgc
^ora <Id
nu6i dudng, gi6o dpc con thi ngudi
d6n-viqc tr6ngnorn, chhrn soc. 6nh hudn{xAu
iin han ch6 quyi:n
cia
nu6i con co q[,en yOu cAu Toa a.^g iru"irap
1fr1m.nor1;.on
an co thti quyet dinh thay d6i nguoi
ich cta con chua th2rnh ni€n. l'da nnu-di d6. vi lqi
dudng nudi con khi c6 don y6u cAu'
ii. ,icp ,roi con vir rnuc c6p
nguyQn cua bd Dqng Thi MCn v0
nu6i con chung: ghi nhan sq tq
Vi cdp dudng
Vdn Linh cAp duOng nudi con chung'
viQc khdngy6u cAu 6ng Nguy6n
sq kh6ng yOu cAu n6n tlQi ddng x6t xu
sdn chung v! no' chung: ducrng
Vi tdi kh6ng xem xdt, gi6i quY6t.
(ba trdrn nghin) dting an phi
D[ng Thi Miln phai chlu 300 000
2. VC 6n phi: bd
nQp t4i Bi6n lai thu tqm rlng an
gia Ainh so thirn, dugc tru vao s5 tidn dd h6n nh6n va
lhi hdnh dn ddn su thdnh
ngiry 251412024 cria Chi cuc
pti, fg pti 1.Ol an s6 0001353 phO tan Uy€n, tinh Binh Duong.
quydn khang cdo bin iin trong thoi han l5 ngiy
sp co rnht tai phiOn td.a c6
Duong
bin 6n
ar.'o"r"g su ving *Aitai pt iOn-rda clugc quydn kh6ng c6o
f.C t"
"eiyiry".
6n dugc niem y6t theo
tu ngAy nhAn du<rc ban 6n hodc bAn
trong tfr"di han 15 ngiy kO quy dinh.
DONG X[.'t' XU So'l llAM Noi nhQn:
l'M. il01
- TAND tinh Binh Duong;
'r
o,'\
ilA\l PllA\ - cllL tQA PIllL,\ -l
- VKSND tinh Binh Duong;
- VKSND thanh ph6 Tin UY6n;
- Chi cuc THADS thirnh
Tin UY€n;
Ph6
- Cdc duong su (2);
xE Thanh Binh, huYQn H6n
- UBND
tinh Binh Phu6c; Qu6n,
- Luu: Vin thu, h6 so, 8.
'I'hi
Iti6n
TOA AN NTIAN DAN
ceNG HoA
xA uor cuu Ncuia vrET NAM
pHo'rnN
TITANH
uyr:N
Doc l{p - Tr,r do - l-Ianh hric
riuu niNs DUoNG
Bin rin s6: 55/2024/I{NGD-S]'
Ngiry 2t/612024
V/v ly llol. tlanh chdp vi'rrrroi con
NH,AN DANH
NTi6C CQNG HoA xA HoI CHU NGHIA
VIET NAM
ToA AN NHAN DAN THANII PH6
TAN UYtN,TiNII niNu Dt/oNG
- Thtinh phnn HQi tting xdt xti'so tlrfim g6m
cd:
Thant phdn ^ Chu roa phiAn rda;
Birl-0'fhi HiOn.
Cac Hoi
+
tlttrtn nlton tlirr.
-;*i
rl
Ong Huj,nh Son Tdy.
Ong Nguydn Thanh Cirr.
+t,
-rda
l
- Thu ky
rin nh6n . . - Thu'ki phi|n rita. r\u Nguvdn fhi My Nhan
dan thdnh pho'fdn [J1 en. tinh I]iuh I)Llon!r.
(!ia{ Vie!-.{iint
sdt nhfrn dftn thdnh pna TAn L/yAn
thant gia phiAn fio:
:.?{:i Ong^ VO Anh Duy - Kiinr siir vien.
Ngdy 21 thdng 6 niln 2024, rai rod
rin nhan dan thdnh pno ran . i,
Uy0n xdt xir so thdnr c6r.rg l<hai vu ii. l.rdn nhin vd.gia.dirih
thu lli s6 r4gl2.o24lrLsT-rtNco
ngay 0?15/,29?1^:i.r1e9
Lranh
ch6p v0 nu6i coni, ilr." qrvoidirr,
ar.
_'],1 !on. xy s6,2)-/20,2a!QDXXSl -r INGr)
"u"al* -0,
nedv 20 thdng 5 nd,r 2024 ;it quyet
ointr hodn phi0n toa sd 2612024/QDS I'-ITNGD ngay
05 thdng 6 ndrn 2024, gita
duong s,,r:
"ric
' Ngtr.ven dott.
Ba Dirrg r hi Min. sinh narn r990:
noi cu tr[: nhd ri6ng Nguydn
t6 4, khu ph6.phLLcic I{Ai. phudng
Th6i Hoa, il."n-pna ij" Y.T 9ir"g,
U"rerl ,rn Bir-rh Duongl c6 don xin ving
nrat.
\gurirr Van Cirrg. sinh ,dr.
l9g5: noi cu tr[: rrha rieng
Nguydn , _ ,..0i,/rr,,(lrg vi.lll ( LIllS. l(' -1.
l(ltu
I,lrtr',,e IIii. phrrirrru
l.lri,
lIii IIoa. tlranl: plro tarr
Uydn] rirrh Ilinh Dr"Lo-ng: van_q mat khone
16 ly clo.
NOI DUNG V\r zrN:
*
Theo do'n klt6i kiln, bdn
tu'khai, qrn trinh giai quyd
vu dn, nguyan don
btr Ddng Th! Mdn trinh bdy;
Vd qtnn h6 hon nhon:
b1 Xaen vd 6ng Nguy6n VIn
Cirng dang k;i. k€t h6n
vdo
;;'et,h lfl:1,^t]lll,:ll I li,.u, han nhan dan xa 1-hanh Binh, huyQn-H*,'q,_, Phuoc. theo.Giay chring nhan
ket hdn sd 16120r I, quydn
sd 0ti20t l. iau khi k6r
hon vg
song nanh phuc
nhurrg bdt ddu tu ndm 202r
thi rhucrng xuy6n xay ^cnong
ra rndu thu^in. cai vd' lorr ti6ng voi nhau.
Nguy.n nhan ri do 6ng
H6ng.cJngubi phu
nt khdc; kh6ng co trdch nhiern voi gia"dinh..
Mdc dt vo chdng nt,ieu
Ian ng"oi tai noi .tryon, tim biQn phrip hdn gin tinh
carn nhung van kh6ng trr"anrr.
Hie, vq-ffi#
,a"g ,y
'
quan tdm d6n nhau n6n tinh cArn kh6ng con. Bd MOn nhfn thAy thAn, kh6ng ai cdn
th6 hdn g6n dugc nta, mpc dich hdn nhAn kh6ng tlat ttugc h4nh phric vq ch6ng kh6ng n6n y6u cAu dugc ly h6n v6i 6ng Cirng.
vg ch6ng c6 02 con chung tOn NguyEn D4ng TAm Nhu, sinh
Vi con chung;
Th6i Ph6t, sinh ngiry 1311012022. Tir l0c sinh con ra nsdy xxxxxxxxxx vir Nguy6n D[ng
iruc ti6p vd thudng xuy6n gdn grii. ch[m.s6c, nu6i c[o'dt1n nay, bir Vfen fa ngudi
cira con vd hiQn cdc con dang s6ng vdi bd du6ng c6c con, n6m bit duqc tdrn sinh [y
bd M6n y6u c5u dugc tryc ti6p nu6i duong 02 con van. Vl v{y, khi vo chdng ly hdn chung.
kh6ng y6u cAu 6ng Cfrng cAp duong nu6i con'
Vi cdp dudng nudi con:
chung: kh6ng y0u cdu Tda 6n giii quy6t'
Vi tdi sdn chung, nq
'foa
gia phi6n
*
Cfing: dd riuoc
6n tri€u tap hSp lQ tham
Bi don 6ng Nguy1n Vdn
chung crlr va hda giAi, tham gia phi€n
viQc giao nQp, ti6p. cin, c6ng khai hqp kiem tra
c6 lii do vd kh6ng c6 vdn bAn trinh bdy toa dcn tan thri hai nhung v6n v6ng [r[t kh6ng y
d6i v6i yOu cdu khdi kiQn cta nguy6n don. ki0n
ph6 tan Uy€n thaln gia phi€n tda ph6t
diQn viQn ki€m s6t nh6n d6n thdnh
Dai bi6u quan di6rn nhu sau:
'foa
'tan
thi\nh phO
l"lytn thp lii vU dn li dung
VC tht tuc t6 tqng:
dn nhdn dan
-
phan dd ti6n hdnh dAy di.cric thu tuc td
quy6n.
trinh giai quy6t vu 6n, ThAm thAm
Qu6
'f4i
qrng
sr,r.
phi6n toa. ltQi d6ng xdt xri vir
quy dinh criaBQ lu{t T6
dAn
tUng Airng theo
l]0 ludt t6 tqng ddn su v€ phi6n toa rnri tv p*trien toa dd thuc hi6n dung quy dlnh cua
tham gia t6 qrng cric tluong sy dd
.ir6p nam pnap^tu6t cria ngudi
,",f;i"lOOi *i uie"
ki6m srit kh6ng co y€u cAu vd ki6n nghi dC
hien dfng quy tinh. Oai diQn ViQn thUc khic phuc vi ph4m tO tung.
vA
Nguy6n Van
tg nguyQn
vu 6n: bd Dqng Thi Ml5n
6ng
- VC nQi dung
!;rns
hqp phap Bd M6n xdc. tlinh vs
c6 ddng ki k6t h6n ld h6n nhAn
chung s6ng rOi rt u,i,
muc dich h6n nhdn khdng d4t
khOng ai iOn quan tAm di5n nhau,
OrE Oa s'6ng ly thdn, "t
Tda 6n trieu tap, ni6m
hon. Bi don 6ng Cilng cld dugc
duoJnen mons rnu6n duqc-ly
vhng mdt kh6ng co li do'
d6 tham gia phi€n tda nhung
la."ran ban t6 tung Veifrqp fC
ki6n cta nguydn don lir co cdn
do do ydu cAu khdi
i<h6ne'c6'van bdn rrinh biy !-ki6n.
dudng con chung ten Nguy6n
va" ye, cAu duoc nuoi
ffiil#;
Vt;;;;h*s1 ua
vd Nguy6n Dqng Th6i Ph6t' sinh.ngiy
Tdrn Nhu, sinh ngiy xxxxxxxxxx D[ng
cAp duong nu6i con, dAy la
y6u
Ciing
! chi tq nguyQn cria inbnOZZ;kh6ng
"ai Ong
chung, no chung: duong sq
x' ghi nh4n. Vi: tdi sin
fr.la. ,Cri ad ngfri HQi d6ng xet ta uror* re, .a, ri" * giai qr'vilincn f['ooe xetn x6t' Tu nhtng phdn tich trcn' d' nghi
y€u ciu khdi kiin cta nguy6n don'
xet xu chAp nfran ioan bQ ffOi Otng
NHANDINH cU/rroaAx:
dugc tham tra t4i phi€n tda
liQu c6 trong h6 so.vu 6n
khi nghien cuu cric tdi
Sau
cldng x6t xt nhdn dinh:
qui tranh lu{n tqi phi6n tda, HQi va can cri rao k'rlt
Vi thil tuc tii nmg:
giii quv6t: d6y li vu 6n h6-n nfan
phip luflt vi thAm quv€n
VA quan hQ
1a-S1a
[1]
Hda'thdnhph6Tdn
rOrgtai t6'4,khuph6P-hudcFI6i'phuongTh6i
dinn,tiAonrint
'l
ph6 Tdn Uy€n
nghi oa dn nhAn ddn thirnh
vd nguyen don dA Uv6n. tinh Binh Duong
tung dan su ndm 2015'
35 vd 39 cua BQ luflt T6
crr-* ,j" .a. #du zs, ;tiffi6,. HQi d6ng xdt x[r x6c dinh r,Lr an rhuoc
th6nr quy6n giii quy6t cria Tda
6n nhdn ddn thdnh pho Tin [Jv0n" tinh I]inh
I)rrnng. .
lil Su thar, gia phiin r.a cria cdc duong su: bi don 6ng Nguy6n Vdn CDng dd duoc roa an tong dat, nicrn yet
hop 16 lan thu hai ciic vdn bzin
t6 tung de tham gia phi6n tda nhung v6ng rn6t kh6ng
co iy ao; nguy0n don c6 don xin
*et *,i'rinq-ai. ro c16, cdn cri vdo cdc Di€r227,228
vit238 cria so tuat T6 tung oa,
,u, uoi oo?g let r,i ti€n hdnh xdt xri vu 6n v6ng mdt
ciic duong su.
'':
ve not dung:
q.r:lle h6n nhdn: bd Eang
ThiMiSn vd 6ng Nguy6n Vdn
Crng c6 ddng , . , ,ll,1Je kii' kdt h6n tai u1i ban nhdn ddn xd
rhanh Bi,h, huyQn Hon
Qudn, tinh Biih phuoc theo Gi6y ch0ng nhdrr ket hon s6 36t2}lt,quyen
s6 OttZOtt,ldL6n nhAn frqp pfrap
Nguy€n clon bd Ddng Thi M€n xric dinh,
rndu thu6n vg ch6ng td do
6ng Cirng cso
phy
ktrdng.qua, tflnr d6, gia dinh.
Bd M6n vd 6ng Ciing hiSn
tai ia ry lc"udi
lo.kl,u.: than vd ca hai ddu kh6ng dua ra
duoc bi6n phrip hdn g6n tinh
c6m ,o .*hong. da vai, -":'\
-du x6cdinh
lilh carn roi
ong cirng vd yeu
duoc Iy
.,rV,,\
h6n.
trinh gi6i
lh.lns...:n
eu6
l.:. ar \ !:Ii,,y dn. hir Mcn khoug dcLr r oa arr cho rhdy ong khong co thl6n chi hoa gini dJ'vf
',!4'',,\ chong doan tg, dong thoi bir Min
ki6n quy6t xin ly hon. Do
cto, co c6n cu-xdc dinh
arl'.] I.ll
giria bl Men vd 6ng-Crng
tdirAm ffeng, aji .a"g.nrrg
.::,li r, T?l lhr{1,"n chdng
i#"e
, i th6 kdo ddi. rnuc dich h6n nh6n kh6ng
d4t duoi, vi6c bd Mciycu
:".:,..,'*:..1
.a, iy r.,on'roi ong Ctng ld c6 co sd chdp
'
nhdn.
,.i
lr'
VA con chung: tll Mj" vd
6ng_Cftng c6 02 con chung
. .l2l
t6n Nguy6n Dang
Nhu' sinh ngdv 07/or20t2
ph6t,
va Nguv6. Eang Thrii
]1m
sini ,gaylittotiozz. Khi ly-h6n..bd.Mdn y6u cau
dr-Loc trp'c-ti6p nroi i',rong
con chung ua-u,ong y€u
cau 6ng Cftng ciip dudng nu6i con.
x?r xtr tlrut.: sau khi vo ch6ng
s6ng ly thrln, bd M6rr truc ti6p .
19i.ding
ch6rn s6c, nu6i dudng 02 chriu Nguy6n
Ddng Tdrn N*,u ,a Nguy6n
phai.b"
Eang ThAi
OO,
ch6u td c6.a,i.i,.r,rap=riA;;Mi;ftors ::::l::i 9..-.Yur,u"o._nuoidu.ong-02
('rl,g
crip drrlng nu6i con. xdt
d6y Id
I:u cau ong
! chi tu nguyen cria bd M6n n€n H6i dong xct xu' ghi rrhdn.
t3l vd tdi san chung vd no- chung:
duong su' kh6,g y6u cau . .
,6n I-r6i d6ng x6t xri kh6ng xern x6t, giAi quy0t.
xet dc,ghi cria dai diQn
[4]
Vi€n Ki6n s6t tai phi6n
toa rdL c6 co sd ch6p nhan.
[5] v6 d, phi hdn nhdn'd gia
crinh so trrdm: cdc du<rng
su phai chiu theo quy diuh.
Vi cdc l€ n.Att,
QUYE,'I'EINII:
Cdn ciL l<lroin I Didu 28: cac
Di0u 35, 141
,22i,22g,23g,266,269,271,2i3
vit 280 cua 86 luAt T6 tung
din su,:
Cdn c[r cac Dieu 5I.
gl. g2. g3 g4
5(r.
vd
cua I..udt Flon nhAn vd giadinhr
cu l)i0Lr 27 Nghi qr)lir
so l1612016/uB'fveHr4
. _ca.
ngiry 30/t212016 crrra
uy ban'fhunng'r-r
hoi khria
Qu6c
I4 quy clinh vd muc tfru,,''.,ien,
g-ia,r, ,nr,
'l'da
Or*,r, vd sri dung rin phi vi 16 phi
/ur;
""O
nguy€n rlon bd Vdng Gip Vdn vd vi6c "ly
nhfln y6u cdu khdi kiQn cria
L Chap
voi bi don 6ng Nguy€n Vdn LI6ng'
hdn, tranh ch6p vC nu6i con"
ly h6n vdi 6ng Nguy6n Vdn Cirng '
quan h€ h6n nhdn:bd Dang Thi M6n dugc
Vi
Nguyan Dflng ldrn Nhu, sinh ngdy xxxxxxxxxx
con chung: giao con chung ten
vi
ping
ctro ba O4ng lhi M6n tryc ti6p nu6i
it ii pnA, sinh nldy ntWzOZZ ,a Ngryen du6'ng.
ddu c6 quydn vd nghia vs tr6ng
MCn vir 6ng Nguy6n Vdn CiLng
Bd D4ng Thi
quy dinh cua phap luflt' Sau khi ly h6n'
nu6i dudng, gido duc con theo norn. chdtn s6c.
vu
con md kh6ng ai dugc
nuOi con co quydn. nghia
thnm nom ng;Ji rhong trlrc ti0p
vi0c thdm ,om d6 cirn trd ho[c gAy
kh6ng trqc ti6p nu6i con tarn-agng c6n trd. Nguoi
gi6o dqrc con thi nguoi
trong nom, charn soc. ntr6i dudng,
ant t"*i*6, Oeni,iec
han ch6 quydn thdm.nom.con cta
con co quy6n y6u cAu Toa An Jung tru."tiep nu6i
Tda in c6 th6 quy6t dinh thay d6i ngudi
Vi lqi ich c,ja conihua thdnh ni6n, ng,rii aO.
nu6i con khi co don y6u cAu'
truc ti6p nu6i con vi rnric cAp duong
bA D[ng Thi M6n ve
con chung: ghi nhfln sq tu nguy0n crJra
Vi cdp &tdng nuoi
Vdn Linh c6p dudng nu6i con chung'
viQc khdngy6u
Nguy6n
"4, Ong
kh6ng y€u cAu n0n [lQi d6ng x6t xu
chung v.d np' chung: duong sr,r
Vi tdi san kh0ng xern x6t, gi6i quY€t.
(ba tram nghin) d6ng 6n phi
Thi Miln phai ch[u ]00 000
2. VC 6n phi: bd D[ng
tai Bi6n lai thu.t4m rlng 6n
thirn, duoc tru v2ro so tidn da nqp
h6n nhAn va gia Ainh so
cqc'Ihi hdnhdndansuthdnh pti,tcpi,i riaanso0001353 ngiry251412024cirachi phO tan UyCn, tinh Binh Duong.
ban an trong thcri han l5 ngdy
phi6n td.a c6 quy6n kh6ng cd,Lo
Duong su c6 mar t?i
6n. Euong s,,r uing raitai pnien toa tlugc quydn kh6ng c6o bAn 6n f.a tt rgayiry0n
clugc ni0m y6t theo
nhan doqt ban dn hoic bAn 6n
tfiOi t
15 ngdy kd tu ngay irong
an quy dlnh.
'l'M.
r XU'So't ttAM
nhfin:
[Ol DONG X[: Noi
- TAND tinh Binh Duong;
PIIIEN ToA
THAM PIIAN - cllu'l-QA
- VKSND tinh Binh Duong;
- VKSND thanh pht5 Tan Uy6nr
t,) -
cuc l-HADS thinh
T6n UY6n: Chi
Ph6
- C6c tluong su (2);
xd Thanh Binh, huYQn H6n
- UBND
tinh Binh Phu6c; QuAn,
d1
- Luu: VIn thu, h6 so, 8.
PF
t*
h i lIi6n
.I.oA
AN NIIAN DAN
CQNG
HOA XA HQI CHU NGHIA
VIET NAM
THANTI PHO'TAN UYEN
D6c I6p - Tu'do - Hgnh
phric
riNu siNH DTIoNG
Ban 6n s6: 55i2024IHNGD-ST
Ngiry 2t/612024
V/v ly h6n. rranh chdp ve nudi con
NHAN DANTI
NIIOC CQNG HOA XA HOI
CHU NGHIA VIET NAM
ToA AN NI{AN DAN.I.HANH
PHo TAN UYTN, TiNH BiNH
H.1
DTIoNG
$
- Thdnh phAn HQi d6ng
xii.so thfrnt
-rdt
g6m cd:
7'hant phlrn - Cht) roa phiAn
rdcr; l:,i,l-d'lhi Hi0n.
Cac I10i tham nhan ddn.
Ong Huj rrir Son 1 61 .
6ng Nguydn Thanh CAn.
flu' k.f philn
-foa
/r)a: Ili NgLLI in Ihi Mj Nhrin
Thu I<1,
6n nhdn dAn rhanh . , _ ph6'l-an [J1 in. linlr I]lrrh [)r-rone.
(jie! Vie!_.{iinr
srit nhAn dfrn rhrinh pnA rAn (}yAn
tham gia phi€n tba:
:.?!i Ong^ Vd Anh Duy - I(iirrr sdr viin.
Ngdy 2l thdng 6 ndnt 2024. tai
rod 6n nh6n dan thdnh ph6 tan , r
Uy6n xdt xri,so thAm c6ng l<hai vu d, h6, nhdn ra.gia.dinh
thu l! s6 14g/2.o24lrLST-HNGo
ngay
-'r-y 0?t5l,2g?1^:i
h6n. tran^
chdf vd nu,,i con.1, rrr." qry.iJi"rri""
.riQc
sq
r INCr) ,-eiv
"u"ai* _e,
r0 rhdng 5 narn tozq iaeuvdt t
i2l7q2-1lQDXXSI
dinh hoan phien Lda sd 26/2024lQDST-l rNGI) ngay
05 thiing 6 ndrn 2024, gitac,ic
du.rrg su,
- Ngt:ven do'n: BA Dang I lri
M6n. sinh rrarn 1990: ncyi cu.
rru: nhd rieng Ngul in
4. khu ph6. ptrrLoc
Itai. phuong lh6i I-Ija,
Y.T 9o"g, tO
,rrrrf-, pr,; ii, U"re,j, ,i"n Binh Duong: c6 dryn xin vdnq rnit.
oi,l', (")rr:r
(
Nurrr i, Vrin iLrrg. sinrr
,arr r9g5: ,oi cu lrt: rrrra ridng
Ngul in ,,. ,..
, va. (
rr,!. ti) r. r\rl,
[)rrtrtie Irri. plrrrirrrr
PIr,r.
ll*i Ioa. tharrh ph.
Tan Uyeri. tr,h Binh t)uong: vAng nrat l<h6ne
16 Iy clo.
NQI DUNG VU AN:
.^Tl:",1do".kh6.i.kiQn.
ban tu.khai, qud trinh giai quy€t
vu an, nguyAn d,n
bd uang 1t|t tvlen lr tlt bqv;
l/e qrro,t lttl lt,)n ttlt,itt.hi
Mjrr va ole Nnuydn VAn (.al.1g
dane ky ket hdn rao ngay 0r/r0/20 ll rai Uy ban nhan
ddn xa rhanh B)nh, huyQn*Hon-q,ian,
iinr, ninn Phuoc. rlreo.uiil e hu'rrg rrrrirr r;it
lron s, J6/20I l. q.1 in so
0r,20|. Sarr khi ker
hon
plruc rrlru.g bat
dAu ru, rrarn zbil rhi
,uyJn *^1 I.u ,.r,u, :::l"li ]i",.hal:1,
.riruong lnuan' car \ a. ro, licllg vni rrrrru.
\eu1 dn nhdn ra do ong Hong
c6 nguoi phu nt klrdc; kh6ng c6 rriich nhi.rn v6i gia
dinh. Mdc dt vn ch6ng
inie, ian ,e:"i l+ir;i .,hrv,r, tirn bi.n phdp han gin tinh
cAnr nhurrg vin kh6ng tiarn.
uie,,
";;;6rg;;.arg,y
).
con. Ild MEn nh{n th6y '
quan tdm d6n nhau n€n tinh c1m khdng
thdn, kh6ng ai cdn
mUc dich h6n nhAn kh6ng dat duqc
the h1n gin duqc nfa,
hanh phnc-vq ch6ng kh6ng nOn yOu cAu duoc ly h6n vdi 6ng Cirng.
Nguy6n E[ng TArr Nhu' sinh
vg chting c6 02 con chung tOn
Vi con chung;
ngiry 1311012022. Tu tric sinh con ra
vd\guyln D[ng Thai Ph6t, sinh neAv 07/01/20i2
xuy€n gAn giri'.chdm s6c' nu6i
MC"i; ngudi irpc ti6p vA thudng .fr"'Aa. nay. bd duongcaccon,narnbatduqctArnsinhl!cuaconvdhiQnc6ccondangs6ngv6ibd
yeu cAu duo. c tr*c ti6p nu6i dudng 02 con
khi vg chdng ly h6n ba Men van. Vi v{y, chung.
y6u cAu 6ng Cfrng cdp dudng nu6i con'
Vi ciip dudng nu6i con:kh6ng
cAu Toa 6n giii quy6t
Vi tdi sdn chung, no chung: LJtdngy0u
'l
gia phien
*
dd duoc oa 6n trieu tap hqp lQ tham
Bi don 6ng Nguydn Vdn Cilng;
chung cir vd hoa gi6i, tham gia phi6n
viQc-giio'nQp, ticp.c{n, c6ng khai hqp kiom tra
c6 ly do vd kh6ng co vin bin trinh bdy
thu hainhung v6n vang mat kh6ng t# ACn tAn y
ydu cAu khdi kiQn ctia nguy0n don' ki0n ddi vdi
DaidiQnViQnki6ms6tnh6nd6nthdnhplrotanUy6ntharngiaphi6ntdaphat bitiu quan di6rn nhu sau:
.Vcthutuct6tqng:Toa6nnhAndin.thirnhpho,tan[Jy0nthpllivp6nlddung
ti6n hdnh div dt.cdc thu tuc td
quy6t ,u 6n, ThAm pnan aa
thA,, qryA;.
nl"h eTai
a;a
phientoa, IlQi d6ngxetxtvi
lu{tT6tpngd6nsv'l ai
t1,ngA,ingtheoquydinhcta'd0
t6 tung ddn sg vd phi6n tda
thuc hiQn dring quy dlnh cua IJO lu6:t
Th; kn Dhion tdi da
rham gia t6 tung cric.duons su dd
hanh phTp'tuqt cria nguui
;;;l;:D6t ;i ,ie"
"i.,6p
ydu cAu vir kien nghi d€
di.en Vien ki6rn sat kh6ng co
thuc hiQn dfng quy dinh. Dai khic phpc vi pharn to tqng.
Nguy6n V-a1
tr,r nguyQn
vp 6n: bd D4ng Thi M€n vd 6ng
- VA nQi dung
!1mS
p phrip Bd MCn xdt. dinh vs
dang t<y tei nOn ld h6n nh6n h-o.
chung s6ng rOi ,ttui,
"b
h6n nhdn kh6ng d4t
ai cdn quan tdm d6n nhau, muc dich
.ttOr* aa s6ng ly thdn, kh6ng ;;;.'.4; ;";;rnu6n rlusc-lv h6n. Bi don ong cirng dd ilusc Toa 6n triQu tflp' ni0m
ving mdt khdng c6 lli do'
iung d0 tham gia phi€n toa nhung
le .a. "uan udn ro ,eifrtp
kidn cta nguy€n don ld c6 cdn
yi kitin. do do ydu cAu khoi
ith6ns.'co'van bAn trinh bay ffi?ilil."1it;;;;h;s1 ui rven yeu ciu du,oc nuoi du6ng con chung r6n Nguy5n oang fa* Nhu, sinh
leil 17lOttiol2 vd Nguv6n D[ng rhdi Phat' sinh ngdv
ld chi tu nguyCn cira
Cirng cip du6ng nudi con, ddy 1i
y€u l3ll"Ol2121;kh6ng
"Ai Ong
chung, no chung: duong sq
xri ghi nh{n. Vd tdi s6n
Ua'rr.,iA. ,C,j ad nifri HQi d6ng-xet f.f,o"* ,e, .a, fi" i" giai qrv6i"c' fi'otg xem xet' Ttr nhrrng phdn tich m6n' d6 nghi
y€u
khoi kiin cta nguy6n don'
chAp nh4n toan bQ
ciu
HQi Atng xdt xu
EINH cu.rr roa AN:
NHAN
dugc thAm tra t4i phi0n tda
liQu.co trong ht
6n
khi nghiCn criu c6c tdi
Sau
.so.vp
d6ng x6t xri nh6n dinh:
qui tranh lufln t4i phi6n tda, HQi vd c[n cri viro klt
Vi thil tuc td tqng:
giai quv6t' dav
nfan.1a31a
quan h0 ph6p luflt vd thAm.quvdn
V0
1l
1l trgn
[1]
"u
Hai' phuong Thai dinh,iiaon.inft rOng tai tO'+, khu ph6-Phuoc
fd1 thdnh ph6 Tdn
'l'oa
thdnh ph6 TAn Uy6n
d6 nghi
6n nhan dan
Duong v?r nguy6n don Uv6n. tinh Binh i1,6iil; Car-*
"I" .a" O"iau ZS,35 vd 39 cua 86 ludt 1'6 tung dAn su ndm 2015,
J
HQi d6ng xet xt xiic dinh vu iin thuoc
th6rn quydn giai quy€t cta Tda
6n nh6n dan thdnh ph6 1-An Ll1,0n. tinh tlinh I)rrorrg.
Ill Su'rharn gia phi0, roa cua ciic duong su: bi cron 6ng Nguyan
vdn Cirng dd . duoc'l-da 6n r6ng.dat, ni0nr ydt ho-p lQ
ldn thf hai cdc vdn uanioiurg
dii tham gia phi6n tda nhung vdng mIt
kh6ng cO iy do; nguy6n don co don
xin *et *,ii,6nsrrat. lo d6, cdn cri vdo c6c Didu 227 228 vit 238
,
cria no tuat T6 tung aan su, Hor
o3?g ,e, ,,,i tidn hdnh xdl xu vu iin vdrrg rndt cdc
duong su.
Vi nQi tlung.
,]Jd
ne h6n. nhan: bz\ Ddng
O.rii
Thi M6n vd 6ng NgLryErr Vdn Crng .
c6 ctdng , , ,t ky k0t h6n tai U1, ban rrhan diin sd Thanh
Binh, huyQn IIon
tinh
euan,
Biih phuoc theo Gi6y chung nhan ket hon s6 36120rr,quy"n
s6 oVzot t, Idir6n nh6n h-op ph6p
Nguy€n don bri Ddng I Iri M6n xiic dinh,
rndu thuan vg ch6ng ld do 6ng
ctng cso nquoi php:r.kl,u.: kh6ng,quan
rim ctdr.r gia dinh. Bd Mdn vir dng
cirng hiEn tai da ry thdn vd cri hai d6u kh6ng dua ra duoc
gu
bi6n ph6p hdn gin tinh carn uo J6ng.
Naen xac dinh h,ln..g...!n linh crrrr rt'ri ong
Cti.ng va yiu cAu duo-c ly h6n. quitrinh
giai
l qu1 i't vtr 6rr. hi \4.1, khorrg tlirr
l-irit art clro thriy ong khong co thicn
chi hoa giai d6'vo chong do?rn ru. dong thoi bi\ Min kiirr quyer
xin ly hon. Do do, co cdn crixiic
di,h ,l?ithri:."q ch6ng gin'a ba Men va
ong blng la rrirn rrqng. ari ,O"e.hr"g
khJ,,g th6 kdo ddi. muc dich h6n nhdn khfrng
crat drLo-c. vi6c ba Mi5; yeu ciu
Iy non"voi ong Cirng ld c6 ccr sd ch6p nhAn.
t2l Ve con chuns: b1 Mjn vri 6ng-Cirng
co 02 con chung t€n Nguy6n -l'drn
Ddng
Nhu. sinh n.eay 07t0U20t2 vd Nguy6n
phdt,
Eqng 1-hrii
sin*h ,rgay\ittotzozz. Khi ly-hon..bd.Mdn ydu cirr cruoc tru'c
ti6p nuoi Juong con chung ua-tnong y6u
cau dng Cftng cAp duo-ng nu6i con.
HQi ding xtlt xir th4': sau lihi
v-o_ch6ng s6ng ry thdn. ba M6n truc
ti6p chdm s6c, nu6i dudng 02 chilu NeLry6n t)dng
ph6t.
TArn Nhu vd Nguy6n Dang Th6i
Do do, riu c1u cta ba Mdn duoc-nr6i cruong
02 chiiu ld co.a,',-",r.t'apnf,6r. nir,.iir"r.r,org
cau one ( tl.ne )/cu
ctrp drrinu nu6i con. xdt day ld y
chi tu nguycrr cta bd M6n n6n
H6i dong rctt su ghi rrltiirr. . .
H6i d6ng x6t xrJr ^ t3l va tdi srin chung vd no- chung: duong su kh6ng yOu cau n€n kh6ng xern x6t, gidi quydt.
[4] xdt dc nghi cta dai cri6n vidn
Ki6m s6t tai phi6n toa rd c6 co
s6 ch6p nhan.
t5l va dn phi hdn nhdn vir gia dinh
so tharn: ciic duong su phai
chiu theo quy din h.
vi c'ac l? trert'
euyE.,. ElNlr:
CErr ctr khoan I Di6u 28: ciic Di6u
35, l4l .22i,228,235,266,269,271,273
vit 280 cta 86 ludt T6 tung ddn su:
cdn c[L ciic {)ieu 5l- 5(r.
g3 g4
8 ]. 82.
va cua Ludt LI6n
nhd, vd gia clinh;
ct t)i0u 27 Nghi qu\a'r so
i26r2or6ruBr-veFll4 ,gity .
,cdn
3oa2r20r6 cria Uy
'['huong ban
vu
hoi khrja quy
Quoc
l4
dinh vd muc rf'rr, nrien,!la,n,
,nr,
q"* IV
'l'oa vd sri dung 6n phi va l€ phi
"".g
an;
Vdng Gip Vdn vC viQc "ly
ydu cdu khdi ki€n crla nguy6n don bd
1. ChAp nhfln
voi b! don 6ng Nguy6n V6n H6ng'
h6n, tranh chAp v6 nu6i con"
dugc ly h6n vdi 6ng NguyEn V6n Ctng'
quan hA h6n nhdn: bA Dang Thi M6n
Vi
'l'dm
D.ng
Nhu. sinh n.gity 07 /0112012
con chung: giao con chung t€n Nguy|n
Vi
phrit,
cho bir D4ng Thi M€n truc ti€p nu6i
Oane Th;i
sinh nfay ntrctZOZ2
vir Nguy6n du0ng.
d6u c6 quyAn vd nghia-vp tr6ng
Thi M6n vd 6ng Nguy6n Vdn C0ng
Bd D4ng
quy dlnh cria phdp luat. sau khi ly h6n,
nu6i du6ng, giio duc con rheo nom, cham s61,
vu.thdm nom con md kh6ng ai dugc
tii5p nu6i con c6 quydn. nghia ngudi kh6ng trlrc
nom dti cdn tr6 ho[c g6y
ti6p nu6i con l4nr-dqng vi4c thdm
cdn trd. Ngudi kh6ng tr*c
nLroi duong, gi6o dqc con thi ngudi
tr6ng norn, chdrn soc,
ant tt"Oni*6, di5n*viqc
ch6 quydn tham.nomcon cta
q['cn y€u cAu Toa hn han
a.rg*u.ii6p nu6i con co
Tda 6n c6 th6 quy6t dlnh thay d6i ngudi
Vi lqi ich cta con chua thdnh ni€n. ng,rf,i AO.
nu6i con khi co don y6u cAu'
tfii ticp nrOi con vir mfc c6p duOng
ghi
su tU nguyQn cira bd D4ng Thi Miin vA
dudng nu6i con chung:
nhin
Vi cdp
Nguy6n Vdn Linh cAp dudng nu6i con chung'
viQc khdngy6u cAi 6ng
y€u c6u n6n FtQi dting xdt xu
chung vd nq chung: ducrng sg kh6ng
Vi tdi sdn kh6ng xem xdt, gi6i quYOt.
(ba trdm nghin) d6ng 6n phi
phi: bd E4ng Thi Mtln phii chiu 300 000
2. VO 6n
da nop tai Bien tai thu.tam ring rin
gia ainh sothim, duoc tru viro s6 tidn h6n nhAn va
0001353 ngity 251412024 c1a Chi cuc'Ihi hirnh 6n d6n sg thdnh pti, tq pfri fia an sO phO tan UyOn, tinh Binh Duong.
c6o bin 6n rrong thbi han l5 ngdy
mat
phien to.a co quydn kh6ng
Duong sq c6
Bi
phi€n rda dugc-quyiin kh6ng c6o bAn an
tt
en. Ouong sq ving rn4it4i f.C
"gayi"y6n
6n tlugc ni€m y6t theo
kC tu ngdy nhfln tlugc birn 6n ho4c b6n
trong ttrii tran 15 ngiy quy d[nh.
.I'M.
Noi nhQn:
IIOI DONG XET XtJ SO'T'}IAM
- TAND tinh Binh Duong;
PIIIEN'I'OA
TIIAM I'IIAN - CIIU-I'QA
- VKSND tinh Binh Duong;
- VKSND thdnh ph6 Trin Uy6n;
1.tr
- Chi cuc THADS thdnh ph6 Tin UY6nr
0
- CAc tluong su (2);
,
xh Thanh Binh, huYQn H6n
- UBND
ia
tinh Binh Ptru6c; QuAn,
- Luu: Vin thu, h6 so, 8.
,
?.
n
.t*
'l'h
j I li6n