Bản án 54 — Vụ án ly hôn về mâu thuẫn gia đình

V/v ty h6n, tranh ch6p vi nu6i con

NHA.N DANH

NUbc CQNG HoA xA Hor cHo NGHIA

vrET NAM

'roA AN Nr-rAN

pHo

DAN TITANH

rAN uyEN, riNn

niNn DIJoNG

p$ P P,f

- Thinh phin t hi ding .ttt .uii str thfrnt gittt cd:

+

I ltonl

. (

ltrt ruLt

tt td,r. lla Le I hi I Iicn.

l)llLtt

l,ltii

zi

Cac HQi thaint nhan dan;

6ng Huj,nh Son TAy.

A

3,td

'l-hanh

Ong Nguy6n

CAn.

' Thr k! phian /aa: I3i NgLr1,6n

rhi M! Nhan Thu ky Toa 6n ,hdn

.

d6n thiinh

'l ph6 an IJ;,en. tinh I]inlr l)u,ong. .. : Dgi rtiQn vign Kiam srit nhfrn dfrn thrinh ph6 Tan uJtan rhrtm gio phian tto: Ong V5 Anh Duy - Ki0nr sdr vi0n.

'rod

Ngdy 2l thlLng 6 nim 2024. tai

6n nh6.

diin.thanh ph6 TAn Uydn xdt xrj,so . 2 thArn c6ng khai vu an hdn nhin vir.gia.clinh

thu l1i s6 1491202411'I_ST_HNGD

ngtry o2.l5l.2o?4

''l-1'

i 0 r'iic

h0rr. rranh chAp v0 nucri con'-'.

theo

dinh dua u, a,-, ,.u ,et

euy6t il rl 2l]i!i'+l'QI)xxs l-l lNot) rrgay 20 rhang

5 ndrn 2024 va

dinh bodn phidn

euy6t toa s6 25l202-1/QI)s'f-l INCi) ngay 05 thring niL*t

6

2024. giiLa cac duong su:

- NguyAn do'n. llit, Vdng Gip VAn..sinh

nam 19g6; noi cu tru: tO a, nru phO Vinh Phuoc. phu'ong Thdi Hda. rhdnJr ph6

TAn Uy6n, rinh Binh Du,ong; c6 don

xin vdng mdt. ,

- Bi tlott.. Ong Ngul i, Vi, Ilong,

g,

sinh nam 19g3; noi cu trt: t6 t<hu phO

'l'hiii Vinh PhtLtrc. phLxrng

Ilda. thinh ph6

TAn Uyen. tinh Binli Dunng;

ving mht kh6ng Ld li do.

NOI DUNG VU,,tN:

*

T'lteo tlon khcti l<i€n, han ru' khai,

clua trinh giai quy€t vu an, nguvan

do,n bd Vong Gip Yin trinh bdt..:

vi clrt,rtt lti lt6n nltr)rt. ba van va

dng NgLry0n vdn FI6ng clang ky k6t h6n

vdo ngal'

'l-hiii

'l

I 7r0I l() I I tai

ban nhijn dan phuong

Floa. thanh. pho- an Uydn. tinh

.LJv [3inh Duong theo Giiy chung nhan k6r

h6n ro-ozlzot l, quyen so 0UzOt l.

1-iong qua trinh chung s6ng. vo chdng Lhr.Ltrng xuy6n

xay ra,.rdu thuan. cal ua. ronii.ng^ri;

,,rrur. Nguy0n nhan Id do 6ng ll6ng thud'r.rg xuydn

dj nl'rdu roi vd ki€rn chuyen,

eav su. danh dap vn conl l<h6ng co lraclr nhiem vcri gia

dinh. Mdc clu vo ch6ng nt,iAu tiingoi

tai noi chuyOn. tirn biOn phdp han gzin tinh c6,

nhurrg vdn kh6ng thann. uion

vo"ch6ng dd

quan tarn d6n nhau nin trnh cdrm kh6ng con. Bd VAn nhAn s6ng ly thAn, kh6ng ai con

th€ han.gan duo-c ntja. n.ruc clich hdn nh6n kh6,g d4t thAy hanh phuc.vo- chdng kh6ng duoc ntn y€u cAu dugc ly hdn voi 6ng I'l6ng.

c6 02 con chung t0n Nguy6n Hdng Nhung, sinh ngdy

Vi con chung: vg chting

Htng, sinh ngdy 191612017. Tu luc sinh con ra cho d6n nay, 0516120ll vd Nguy[n Huy

xuyCn gan gui. chdm s6c. nuoi dudng cdc con, bn VAn ld ngudi truc titip vd thudng

vd hi6n cdc con dang s6ng v<ri b2r vAn. Vi vfly, khi ndm bit duq"c tArn sinh ly cria con

Vdn y€u cAu dugc truc ti6p nu6i duCmg 02 con chung'

vg ch6ng ly h6n bd

con:khdng y6u cAu 6ng I'l6ng c6p dudng nu6i con'

Vi cdp fudng nudi

khdng y6r'r cAu I'da 6n giAi quyilt'

Vi tdi sdn chung, nq chung.

*

'l'da

gia phi6n

tt6ng: dd duqc

dn trieu tip htlp lQ tham

Bi don 6ng Ngu1,an Vdn

chirng cu vir hoa giiii" tham gia phi6n hqp ki6m tra viQc giao nQp, ti6p. c4n, c6ng khai

co li do vd kh6ng co vdn bAn trinh bdy tOa den lAn thri hai nhung vAn ,ing mat khong

v6i yOu cAu khdi kiQn cria nguy€n d<rn. ki6n dOi ;;

ph6 l'an UyOn tham gia phi6n tda ph6t

E4i diQn ViQn kiri*r set nhan d6n thdnh bi6u quan di6m nhu sau:

'tan

nhdn c16n thirnh phO

Uy0n thu Ii vq 6n ld dung

- Ve tht tuc t5 tung: Tda 6n

q;a

glai quy6t v!, hn, lhAm phan da ti6. hanh <li.v- dt.cac thu tpc t6 *,A. qrven.

,.inh

'l4i

dAn s;1.

phi€n tda. t l0i dong xet xri v2t tUng dtlng theo quy dinh cria B0 1u0t T6 tung

quy dinh cua l]0 lu4t td tr,rng ddn su ve phi€n toa Th; ki phien toa dd thyc hiQn dnng

cta nguri tham gia to t*ng cdc duong sq dd so th6in. DOi vOi viec chip hanh phTp luat

sdt kh6ng c6 y6u cAu vd ki6n nghl d6

hiQn ding quy dinh. Dai di0n ViQn ki6m thqc khic phr,rc vi pham to tung.

VAn vir 6ng Nguy6n Vdn Ildng tg nguyQn

- VC nQi dung vr,r 6n: bir Vdng Gip

h6n nhin hc.rp phAp. lla VAn xac dinh vg

voi nhau, co ddng ki kct h6n ld chung s6ng

quan tAm d6n-nhau^ nruc dich h6n nhAn kh6ng dat ctOn! aa s-6ng ly thAn, kh6ng ai con

'fda

Bi don 6ng Hd,g dd rlugc

6n trigu tdp, ni€m 6uoc n6n mong mu6n duoc ly h6n.

gia phi6n toa nhung ving mdt kh6ng c6 ly do.

le cdc"van bnn tO t*ng d0 rharn Veihqp

y6u cdu khoi kiQn cria nguyen don lir c6 c[n

vdn bin trinh bdy kiiin, do tlo lhOng-cO

1i

y6u iA, doq. nudi dudng con chung t6n Nguy6n

.t-ap ,fra, VA con chung, bi VAn ",i'

Fltlg, sinh ngdy l916/2017; kh6ng

sinh ngdy 05/612011 vdNguySn Huy H6neNhuns,

nu6i con, dAy la

veuI6u OnifiOne.Ap OuO"g

i chi tr,r.guyen cua bi Dung n6n d€

uo chung: duong sr,r kh6ng yeu cdu

dSne xelxu'ehi nnan. Ve tdi sdn chung. nshi H6i

phAn tich tr6n, d6 ngh; HQi dong x6t

dn giAi qiy6t n6n-khdng xem xdr. Tu nhtng T"oa

bQ y6u cAu kh6i kiQn cta nguydn don.

xri cnAp nnan todn

NHANDINH Cuzurol AN:

h6.str'.vq 6n dutrc thdrrr tra lqri phion toa

khi nghi€n cuu cac tiri liqu.co trorg

Sau

phi6n toa. t Ioi d[rng xet xu r.rhAn dinh: vd cdn cf vdo k6t quri tranh ludn tqi

Vi thu tuc td qng:

giai

day ld vu 6n h6n nhAn vir gia

quan h.Q ph6p lu{t vd thAm quydn

c1uy6t:

VA

[1]

ftruOc, ptruO"g Th6i Hda, thanh ph6 Tan

bi don sinh s6ng tai tO b, tfru pnO tinh dinh,

'lda

ph6 Tdn Uydn

vir nguy6n don dd nghi

6n nh6n d6n thAnh Uy6n, tinh Binh Duong

"t'6

2015,

vd 39 cLra I]Q luQt

tqrng dAn su nlm gidi quy6t. Cdn c[r vdo c6c EiAu 28,35 HQi c16ng xet xLi x6c clinh ,u

6rr thu6c tha,r quydn giii quyrit

cta Tda 6n nhan ddn thdnh ph6 1'An Uydn. tinh Uinh

Duong.

l2l Su rham gia phien tc\a sir..5.

du.o.ng su.: bi don 6ng Nguydn

Vdn H6ng cld du'rrc Ioa 6n rorra dat. ,icrrr rcr

lro-p li tin rtiu hai cac varr

;.;, i;',;;g ;; if,r,,

*,^ phi6n toa nhu'ng v6ne nrar khong

co l1i do: nguvdn clon co cion

xin -lirJ.l,arg ,"ai O" do, can cu vdo ciic Di6u 227. 228

g6

va 238 cui

luat T6 rung

- '-'-'

aa,r.u. ii0i O3?g.e, Li6rr hanh \cl \r't \ u in r ang ntat

"n

cac duo,,g s,.r.

Vi noi &rng;

h6 h6n nh?in: bd Vong Gip VAn

vd 6ng Nguy6n Vdn H6ng co . . . ll] Je Uyan

ddng ky k€r h6n tai

ban rrrrar

phudng

din

Thrii IIda. rtanrrlrro

.uy

ran uyen,?intr einn Duorrg theo Gidy chfrng ,hdn

kit Iion so 6zlzo[, quy€n

s6 01/201 r ngity 17r0u20r1, ld h6n nhdn hqp ph6p.

,

Nguy0n don bi Vong Cip Van

x6c clinli. mAu thu6n vo ch6ng .

ld do 6ng il6ng

I

ri.gAv su.. cl6rrh d6p vo

con. kh6ng quan ta,"'at1r-glu lllid"q )r,ilr,di .hAu

.i,.,f,. na v n \aong rrone rrien tai

di 11 rrrin racahai ddu

khong dua ra du.oc biEn ph6p

hdn pa,

lr,rr carrr r o chorrc. Ba Va, rrc

dirrlr klrong corr lirrrr carn voi

ong l-rong va eu cdu

5

lr hon.

rrinlr giLii ,.g,,1

'r,il

QLrri

ir r,,,, dr. o.g Hong kh6ng

!y'oc

crdn

a,r.iroiriay ong kh6ng c6 thiOn chi hoa gizii

tjc',tr chong doa. tu" o-ong

tnJi bd v6n ki6n qrycliin

ry h6r.r. Do do. c6 cdn ciL xric

dinh mdu thuan vo ch6ng giira

ba var va ong u[rig ia

t.a,i.' trong, doi

r<horg_thc

I<co dai. rnuc crclirrln nhan

.s6ng.crrung

l<h6ng dat du,o-c, viec

bir V6n ydu cau 11, h6n voi 6ng IIong

li co co so chlrp nharr.

l2l V0 con chung: bii v6n vd-Ons

lr6ng co 02 con crrung

tdn Nguy6n I-r6ng Nhung. sinh ,gr)1 05/(>/201

l. r'ir Nguyin IILry unng.

sinh ngiry to/olzotz.

rii ty non, ba VAn ydu cAu cl,o-c rruc ti.p

nudi iuong.nn .l,iif

r.l,:;g ylr"}",;;r;nd;#; dudng nu6i

"u

con.

cling xdr xi rhiy, t.u.1khi v.o.

ch6ng s6ng ry rh6n, bir Vdn

.Hai

rruc ti6p chdm s6c, ^. nu6i du6'ng 02 chiiu Ngu1,6,

I[6ng Nhung ua Ngryen

IIuy l{trng. Oo aO,

fOr.Ar.t, bii vanduoc nLrdi dudng 02 chau

Ia co cin c* crrap nhan.

sa vIn kh6niver.au

org

\cr ciay lir chi tu,nguy'en

1,

cua b?r VAn,re,, Hfi targ

*, ru lltl,T-::, dur)n_s nu6i con. 9nt n n:l r1

t3l ve tdi san chu..q'a no-

chung: durrng su'kh6ng y6u

..

cau nOn H6i d6ng xdt

xri kh6ng xern xdt, gi6i quy0r.

xet do nghi cLia tlai cii.n

f4l

vi6n Ki6rr sat rai phi6n

toa rir c6 co sd chap

nh6n.

[r] vc rin phi ht}r ,rri,in r''i)

eia crinh so thiinr: cdc duons

su. phrii chiu tlieo

cluy u,.,.(lIn tl

tr/i cdc ld n'An,

QUYET DINI{:

c,n cu i<hoan I Di6,281

cdc Diiiu 35, )41

.221 .22g,238.266.26g,271,213

vit 280 crla Bo luat f6 tung

dlin sr"r,r

Cin c[r circ DiOu 51. 56. g

g4

l. g2" g3 va cta

l.udt H6n nhAn vd gia

dinh;

cdn cir l)ieu 27 Nghi qrydl

s6 326r2or6ruB,-verr4,gdy

30/1212016 cira Uy ban Thuong'u

h6i

eu6c

l<hoa l4 quy tlinh

v6 miLc,f',r,-,rrie,r,"*,'a,",

rnr,,r*

,,

'lt)a

Or* vir st dung rin phi vd l€ ph

i

rin;

Vdng Cip Vdn vd vi0c "lv

cira nguyen don bir

L ChAp nhin ydu cAu trhoi ki6n

bi don 6ngN-eLr1'0rl Virrr Ilong'

chAp vd nr-16i con" voi h6n, tranh

hirn'iri r)ngNgtrl'6nVrinl16'9.

vongGipVAnclLroclr

viquattltalrc,nlui,;bir

Viconchtng'.giaoconchrrngt6nNguy6nllongNhr-rng.sinhngZry05/6/20llvd

von*e Cip Vin trr,rc ti6p nu6i dudng'

ngity lgrc72ofi cio-ba Nguy6n F{uy Htn[, slnh

ctt quyiln vd nghia vp tr6ng

6ng Nguy6n Van tl6ng ddu

Ba Vong Gip VAn va

qtry

c0a phdp luflt Sau khi ly h6n'

giAo tiqc con theo

dinh nom. chdm sO", nuOi duOng, ,g;;f kh6"g tr,.c ti6p nuOi."un co quy6n. nghia vu rhf,m nom con ,ra kh6.g ai duoc

'con

nor.,., cli can trti hodc giy

nu6i

lam-dr.rng Vi6c thirm

trtr.. Nguoi khong trr.Lc ti6p cirn

gitio dL.rc con thi ngutr'i

,om. chdrn soc. ntroi du'6ng.

rr-0"_*" ra, aa,

trong a"r-'

"ie.

hart.cht, q'y9:

in yeu cau -l oa iin

,lr"g

lli'l ll"]i:":^::1

"u'.llap ,ruoi corr co qu1

co the quyet clinh thay dor nguor

con chua thAnh niOn, Tda an

ngr:Oi AO. Vi lgi ich cita

con khi c6 do-r'r ydu cAu'

con vir rnuc cAp duOng nu6i tiUc tiOp nu6i

c[ra bi)r Vong Gip VAn v0

chtLng. ghinhan sr,L tunguyen

vi cilp ctu6.ng nu6i con

cAp du'0ng nttoi cotr chttttg'

.Ali Ong Nguy6n Van Il6ng viQc kh6ngydu

Vitdisanchungv'atlo'clltulg-.duollgsLtlihongy0trcautl0nltQid6ngxdtxLL

xcrn xet. giai quYet. l<horrg

nghin) d6ng 6n phi

phai chiu lOu 000 (ba tr6m

dn phi: b2r Vong Gip Van

2. Vd

tlian lai thu tam ung 6n

i,.l,q. tri, vao so ri€n cli nQp tqri

nhan va gia dinh so thirn, h6n

ciraChicuc-lhi hinh6ndAnsuthiinh

ldaansO000t35d ngiy251412024 pfri,iCpfrf pnO tan UY0n, tinh Binh Duong'

bln hn trorlg thtri ha, 15 ngdy

phidn to., co qu)in liharrpl ,. iio

Duo,g su co mat tai

c1uy6n-ld6ng^c6o bdLn dn

maitai phiin toa cluo'c

r.e tir rgdylryon an. ouoif s,-1 uitng

dn clugc ni6m y6t theo

dlro.." bdn 6n hodc biin

ts ngay ke tl.ngay ,ih4n tr"rg,n""i trqn qLry dinh.

'r'M.

llol DOt\(; Xt.',r x('so'rllAM Noi nhfn:

Duong;

'I

(

PIIIT-N IOA

- TAND tinh Binh

I'IIAN - III IQA

HAM

- VKSN D tinh Binh DtLong;

? ii

- VKSND thanh ph6 Ten Uyenl

THADS th?rnh

IArr UYdn;

- Chi cuc

Ph6

- C6c duong sP (2); UBND phudng Th6i Hda, thdnh Plt6 - TAn Uydn, tinh Binh Duong;

- l.rru: V6n thu. h6 so, 8.

I

hiuicn